Go to ...

RSS Feed

Thermodynamic Failure: Phase 2

“Most people aren’t paying attention. Most people have no idea what’s going on. Industrial civilization is already having serious health problems and heart palpitations. By 2020, industrial civilization’s going to suffer a massive stroke. By 2025, it will be in hospice. By 2030, it will be dead,” writes the anonymous author of Articulating The Future.

Anonymous, Articulating the Future

Which catchy phrase best captures the pot of boiling water we find ourselves in? Time is running out. We are at the tipping point. The dominos are falling. Whichever one we use, one thing is clear: a fundamental shift in fossil fuel use is underway. Phase 1 was the peak of conventional oil in 2005, with the ensuing GFC (global financial crisis) in 2008, papered over by massive debt conjured out of thin air by the financial manipulator magicians at the Federal Reserve. Phase 2 starts with the growing ineffectiveness of these financial measures against stark net energy realities.

Let me set the stage, and reiterate the premise for those who haven’t read other posts of mine. There is a great deal of difference between conventional and unconventional sources of oil. The former was cheap and relatively easy to extract, the latter is much more difficult and costly. Underlying this though is the EROEI (energy return on energy invested). If you kept giving someone a dollar and continually got back 100, you’d be making money so fast your head would spin. Imagine if you then used this money to invest in a lavish lifestyle with multiple houses, a garage full of amazing cars, a fleet of super-yachts, and staffed hundreds of people full time to take care of all your properties and cater to your every whim.

Then imagine that as time went on you got back less and less money for every dollar you gave. Eventually you wouldn’t be able to afford all those lavish things. You’d have to cut back. You could, perhaps, once things got seriously tight, go into debt to keep up your lifestyle, but you’d have to go into the red on the ledger books in order to do so. And this could not continue indefinitely so long as you continued to receive less and less money back for every dollar you gave.

This is precisely the situation we as a civilization have come to. We built industrial civilization on high EROEI ratios. Numbers generated from multiple studies give estimates of 100:1 returns at the beginning. Today we are down to a total global ratio for all liquids at about a 14:1 return rate. Which is interesting because this is actually the ratio that Charles Hall, one of the founders of the EROEI methodology, concludes is about the minimum needed to prevent collapse. And the ratio numbers inexorably decline no matter what we do.

After the peak of conventional oil in 2005, we were given breathing room from a total production peak through unconventional sources of oil such as tar sands, shale, fracking, and deep offshore wells. But these sources are far more energy-intensive to procure as well as prohibitively expensive; the only way companies were able to extract from them was by going into massive debt. The unconventional oil that we have gone so in debt to acquire notoriously provides a small fraction of the net energy we’ve come to expect from conventional oil sources.

The problem of eroding energy profitability is hard to deal with partly because the decline is happening so fast… Oil no longer provides as much of a stimulus to the economy, which just can’t grow as it did before, and this in turn sets in motion a self-reinforcing feedback loop of stagnating or falling labor productivity, falling wages, falling consumption, reduced ability to re-pay debt, failure to invest in future energy productivity, falling energy supplies, falling tax revenues, and so on. How long can debt continue to substitute for energy before the next traumatic phase of this feedback process begins in earnest?    – Richard Heinberg  [Source]

So now we come to the core of the issue. The industry is plagued by two main things: discoveries and future investments. Both are by-products of the two things already mentioned: we are out of the cheap, easy to extract oil, and what is left has an ever-lower net energy return.

We’ve been building civilization on the huge discoveries between 1950 and 1980 or so depicted on this graph. Clearly production cannot continue apace for much longer.
Notice that the trendline starts really going up at about the year 2005.
This graphic shows how, as energy costs of exploration, extraction, transport, processing, and distributing rise, the net energy left over for economic growth decreases.
​In this chart we can see that after the global financial crisis in ’08 there was a historic amount of spending towards more and more oil production. All of which was debt-based, as I showed in this article. But as we saw with the earlier graph, there has not been a commensurate amount of discoveries. We’ve spent all that money to dig out horribly low net energy unconventional oil because we are not discovering any better sources. This is clearly ending. Companies are realizing that they cannot profit from it, and are no longer investing in it – most are going bankrupt, some are treading water.

Conclusion:​All of this adds up to one thing: we’re about to head into a new era. The thermodynamic collapse is hastening a day of reckoning, way sooner than most people think. But don’t just take my word for it. The CEO of Saudi Aramco, Amin Nasser, was recently (July, 2017) quoted at the World Petroleum Congress in Istanbul as saying that the world is heading towards an oil supply shortage before too long as a result of falling discoveries of new conventional oil reserves and steep drops in new investment. 

At that same conference, Mark Richard, who is the senior vice president for global business development at Halliburton, said that the industry’s slashing of about $2 trillion in investments will weigh heavily on the market in a few years when oil supplies fail to keep up with demand and will lead to massive oil price shocks when the market catches up – according to him, somewhere around 2020-2021.​Remember, in 2008, oil prices spiked to $147 a barrel; then we had the global financial crisis. This is the “massive stroke” I said industrial civilization will have by about 2020. Once this thing hits, things will start deteriorating much more quickly.

The second phase of the thermodynamic collapse starts when the growing ineffectiveness of these financial measures against stark net energy realities hits a brick wall. Are you ready for phase 2?


2020: A Marker For Collapse
Articulating the Future
The real question is when will the next big event occur that shocks the system significantly? And the answer to that, as far as I can discern, is a massive oil price shock and shortages situation that should occur around 2020, give or take a year, according to all the industry top dogs. Saudi Aramco, Haliburton, the CEO of Shell, and many others have been warning about this lately.


Special Feature: Three views from the global economy’s energy cliff
Here are three leading observers on the world’s increasingly shaky energy situation. Minqui Li presents a through-going analysis of the global energy scenario from 2018-2050 based on the latest data, Kurt Cobb suggests that ‘peak oil’ maybe a process, rather than a event, while Chris Martenson issues a stark warning on the coming oil crash.

Our energy problem is about quantity, not just quality
Gail Tverberg, Our Finite World
Reading about energy today, it’s easy to get the impression that our energy problem is a quality problem—some energy is polluting; other energy is hoped to be less polluting. There’s a different issue that we are not being told about. It’s the fact that having enough energy – quantity – is extremely important, as well.

Globalization is reaching its limits; here’s why
Gail Tverberg
We have identified two different limits to globalization. One has to do with limits on the amount of goods and services that developed countries can absorb before those imports unduly disrupt local economies. The other occurs because of the sensitivity of many developing nations to low commodity prices, because they are exporters of these commodities.

Brace for the coming oil, food and financial crash
Nafeez Ahmed, Medium.com
A new research study by HSBC on global oil supply shows that the bulk of the world’s oil production has peaked and is now in decline. Welcome to a new age of permanent economic recession driven by our ongoing dependence on dirty, expensive, difficult oil — unless we choose a fundamentally different path.


(Visited 257 times, 1 visits today)

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

2 Responses “Thermodynamic Failure: Phase 2”

    22nd April 2019 at 12:03 pm

    Industrialisation is the effect of a wrong world view in which man tried to establish the supremacy over other living beings and consequently exploited the whole earth. Industrialisation is the natural way of man’s life as Gandhi said and cannot be the way of future. It cannot assure justice to anyone. It spoiled the whole earth and harmony among the human beings and other specious. Even though I am an engineer , I have no hope of any human freedom by way of industrialisation. .

  2. 22nd April 2019 at 3:15 pm

    Get comfortable with the idea of “problems without solutions.” These are called “wicked” problems, and lie at the heart of a complex systems view of the world.

    First, we musst learn to think. Then we must learn to think differently.

    Read Rittel & Webber, “Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

More Stories From Economy